Four reviewers, eleven comments, one list of decisions.
Paste conflicting stakeholder feedback and get back a list sorted into what to do, what needs a decision, and what you are not doing.
After a review round, the temptation is to apply every comment in the order it arrived. When two reviewers want opposite things, the result pleases neither, and the next round starts with new comments about the compromise.
Feedback Consolidation logs each comment with its source, groups them by element, and sorts them into fixes, change requests, preferences, and questions. It names each conflict plainly, adds a recommendation tied to the brief, and assigns a decider and a date. Nothing is decided on anyone's behalf.
What it produces.
- →A numbered log of every comment with its source
- →Comments classified as fix, change, preference, or question
- →A list of conflicts with a recommendation and a decider
- →One decision list ordered: will do, needs a decision, not doing
- ✦Project managers handling multi-person approvals
- ✦Designers and writers receiving contradictory comments
- ✦Account leads who have to go back to the client with a clear question
- →feedback-consolidation.zip: a native Claude Skill. Upload to Settings → Skills in Claude, or unzip to
~/.claude/skills/ - →feedback-consolidation-skill.md: plain markdown. Works in ChatGPT Custom GPTs, Gemini, Claude Projects, agent system prompts, anywhere
- →A README inside the zip with install steps for Claude, ChatGPT, and Gemini
What it does with a real question.
I've got three rounds of notes on the homepage redesign from our client's CMO, head of sales, and legal counsel, all sent Tuesday. The CMO wants the hero video removed, sales wants it larger, and legal needs the pricing disclaimer above the fold. Launch is March 14, so I need one decision list.
Start by separating the one real conflict from the two requirements. The CMO and head of sales are giving opposite instructions on the hero video: remove it versus make it larger. That is a genuine decision, and it needs one named person with sign-off, most likely the client's CMO or whoever owns the homepage brief. Legal's note is different. A pricing disclaimer above the fold is a compliance requirement, not a preference, so it goes straight into the "will do" section with no vote attached. Your only job there is to check how it interacts with the video decision, since a larger hero pushes the disclaimer down and a removed one makes room for it.
My recommendation is to tie the video choice to the brief's goal. If the page exists to qualify leads without a call, I would lean toward keeping the video at its current size with a static poster frame, which gives sales visibility and gives the CMO a lighter page. Put that forward as a recommendation, not a ruling, and show the layout consequence of each option so they decide with the tradeoff visible.
Next move: send one short email today to the CMO and head of sales, copying legal, stating the video question as a single either/or, with the disclaimer already confirmed as in. Ask for a decision by Friday. That leaves a full week before March 14 for build and a legal review pass on the final layout.
The full Playbook runs the whole procedure and writes the complete deliverable, not this excerpt.
Written by claude-sonnet-5-5 with this Playbook loaded, 2026-10-11. Checked automatically for length and for copied framework text.
No subscription · free updates within v1.x
Works as a Claude Skill (.zip) and as a plain .md for ChatGPT, Gemini & every LLM
Delivered to your email within 60 seconds · Secured by Stripe
Price includes UK VAT where applicable
Before you buy.
How is this different from just asking Claude directly?
Asked cold, Claude merges the comments into one tidy summary and may quietly pick a side. This keeps every comment accounted for, makes each contradiction visible, and sends the decision to the person with authority.
How is this different from a Tool?
Playbooks are systematically produced to a fixed template and priced accordingly ($12.99). Tools are hand-built, one at a time, and go deeper ($39 to $199). A Playbook gives you a reliable method for routine work; a Tool is for when the judgment matters more than the format.
Will this work with ChatGPT, Gemini, and other LLMs?
Yes. You get a native Claude Skill (.zip) that auto-invokes in Claude, plus a plain .md you can paste into a ChatGPT Custom GPT, a Gemini system prompt, or any LLM. The procedure travels with the file.
Can I share this with my team?
It's licensed for your own personal and professional use. The output it produces is yours to circulate. To put the Playbook itself in the hands of a whole team, email hello@authority.md about team licensing.
What if it doesn't work for me?
If the file hasn't been delivered, or arrives defective or empty, we refund in full: see our refund policy.